$name1 and her best friend Imogen, part-time lovers, plot to seat the carpenter they both fancy between them at dinner, and discover that planned accidents are the best kind.
The plan was Imogen’s, and like all of Imogen’s plans it began with a bottle of gin and a perfectly straight face.
“Hear me out,” she said, topping up $name1’s glass. They were on the roof terrace of Imogen’s flat in Brighton, wrapped in blankets against the sea breeze, the lights of the pier flickering below. It was a warm September night. They had been friends for ten years, lovers on and off for three of them, and for the last six months they had been something neither of them had a name for. “We both like Theo.”
“Everybody likes Theo.”
“No, I mean we both like him. Like that.”
$name1 choked on her gin. “Imogen.”
“Don’t pretend. I saw you at the barbecue. You looked at his forearms like they owed you money.”
“His forearms are very well made.”
“Exactly.” Imogen settled back with the air of a general unveiling a map. “So here’s what I propose. He’s coming for dinner on Friday. I’ve told him it’s just me and a couple of friends. We feed him. We get him a bit drunk. And then we both happen to be, you know…”
“Happen to be what?”
“Lying on the sofa. Very close. Looking sleepy.” She waved a hand. “Natural.”
“Nothing about that is natural.”
“It’s accidental. Accidentally on purpose.”
$name1 laughed until she was gasping. But she did not say no. She could not stop thinking about Theo, thirty-four, a carpenter with sawdust in his hair and a lazy slow smile and big square hands that looked as if they could hold up a house. She had caught Imogen watching him too. Somewhere between the second and third look, the idea had stopped being a joke.
“What if he says no?”
“Then we eat the cheesecake and never speak of it.”
“What if he says yes?”
Imogen smiled slowly. “Then I think we’ll both be very glad.”
On Friday, Theo arrived at seven with a bottle of Rioja and a bunch of sunflowers and the nervous look of a man who suspected something. Imogen had made a lamb tagine. $name1 had lit every candle in the flat. They sat on the floor around a low table, eating with their fingers, laughing too loudly, and the wine went down fast. By ten, Theo’s shirt was untucked, his sleeves were rolled up, and his head was tipped back against the sofa cushions.
“I should go,” he said, without moving.
“You really shouldn’t,” said Imogen.
“It’s late.”
“It’s Friday. It’s barely evening.” She patted the sofa beside her. “Come here. Sit down.”
He sat. $name1 took the cushion on his other side, and the sofa dipped, and suddenly his thigh was pressed warm against hers on one side and Imogen’s on the other. Nobody said anything. The record on the turntable crackled to the end of a side. The room went hushed.
“Is something going on?” Theo asked carefully.
“Why do you ask?”
“Because you two keep smiling at each other like cats in a dairy.”
Imogen turned her face to his. “Would it be so awful if there was?”
He looked at her. He looked at $name1. A slow flush spread up his neck, and then he laughed, soft and disbelieving, and rubbed a hand over his jaw. “I think,” he said, “that I’ve had a very long day and I’m not going to survive this.”
“Do you want to?”
“God, yes.”
“Then I’d start by kissing one of us.”
“Which one?”
“Either.” Imogen glanced across him at $name1. “Both.”
He turned to $name1 first. His eyes asked permission. She nodded, and he leaned in and kissed her, warm and careful and tasting of Rioja. $name1 shut her eyes and kissed him back, her hand coming up to his chest. Then she felt Imogen’s mouth press against his neck, and Theo shuddered between them.
“Oh,” he breathed. “Oh, that’s…”
“Good?”
“I might need to lie down.”
“That,” said Imogen, “is the general idea.”
They moved to the bedroom in a laughing tangle, trailing shoes and sunflower petals. Imogen’s bed was wide and low, heaped with cushions. She pushed Theo gently onto it and climbed on top of him, kissing him deeply, while $name1 knelt behind and slid his shirt up and over his head. His back was broad and warm, a faint map of old scars from the workshop. She kissed each one.
“Please,” he said, to nobody in particular. “Please, whatever you’re doing.”
Imogen was already unbuckling his belt. She pulled his jeans and boxers down and he lay naked between them, long and golden and very hard. $name1 felt her mouth go dry. He was beautiful. Strong thighs, a flat stomach, a thick cock that curved against his belly. Imogen wrapped her hand around it and stroked once, and he groaned.
“Look at him,” she said to $name1.
“I’m looking.”
“Don’t you want a taste?”
“I do.”
She shed her dress. Imogen shed hers. They knelt on either side of him in their underwear, and Imogen offered $name1 the base of his cock like a gift. She bent and licked a long stripe up the shaft. Theo’s hips jumped. She took the head in her mouth, and Imogen kissed down the side, and between them they worked him, one mouth on the tip, the other trailing wet kisses along the length, until he was saying their names over and over, helplessly.
“I’m not going to last.”
“You’re not supposed to last,” Imogen said. “Not the first time.”
“The first time?”
“We have all weekend.”
He laughed, a ragged sound, and then groaned again as $name1 took him deeper. She moved her head up and down, slow and slick, while Imogen rolled his balls in her palm, and she felt him swell against her tongue. She pulled away just in time. He gasped.
“God, I nearly…”
“Not yet,” said Imogen. “I want you inside me first.”
She reached into the bedside drawer for a condom, and rolled it onto him herself, with a steady hand, then straddled his hips and sank down. They both moaned. $name1 settled beside them and ran her hands over Imogen’s back, her shoulders, her breasts, and Imogen leaned over and pulled her into a hungry kiss.
“Sit on his face,” Imogen gasped, riding him in long slow rolls. “He’ll love it.”
“Will he?”
“Try.”
$name1 hesitated only a moment. Then she climbed over Theo’s chest and lowered herself, knees on either side of his head. His hands found her hips at once. His tongue slid hot and eager against her, and she cried out and gripped the headboard.
“Oh. Oh, that’s good. That’s very good.”
He ate her hungrily. His beard rasped against her inner thighs, and his lips closed over her clit, sucking, and she heard Imogen laughing breathlessly above her, still rocking on his cock. The three of them moved together in a slow, panting rhythm. $name1 reached out and cupped Imogen’s breast and thumbed the nipple, and Imogen leaned in and kissed her again, deep and open.
“I’m close,” Imogen warned. “Come with me, love.”
“I’m trying.”
“Try harder.”
They came almost together, Imogen first, with a long shuddering cry, and $name1 a breath behind, toppling forward as Theo’s tongue flicked her over the edge. She felt Imogen’s fingers clutching her hand. Theo groaned into her thigh and thrust up hard, once, twice, and came, hips jerking. Then they all collapsed in a heap.
Nobody spoke for a long time. Theo lay between them, chest heaving, an arm around each woman.
“Well,” he said at last. “I don’t think that was an accident.”
“Accidentally on purpose,” said Imogen.
“I’m going to say yes to dinner more often.”
“We’ll hold you to it,” said $name1, and kissed his shoulder, and laid her head in the warm hollow of his arm.
They slept in a heap, and in the morning the light through the thin curtains was pale gold. $name1 woke first, to the sight of Theo’s hand resting heavy on her hip. Imogen lay on his other side with one leg thrown over his thigh, hair wild, already awake and smiling lazily at the ceiling.
“Good morning,” Imogen murmured.
“Is it?”
“I think it will be.”
Theo stirred, hard against $name1’s hip, and she slid a hand down and wrapped it around him. He woke with a long groan and turned toward her. “Again?” he asked, rough with sleep.
“If you can manage.”
“I think I can manage.”
He kissed her slowly. She rolled onto her back and pulled him over her, and he pressed into her with one long, easy push, while Imogen propped herself on an elbow beside them, watching, her hand sliding down between her own thighs. “Don’t stop on my account,” she purred. “I’m enjoying the view.”
$name1 locked her ankles behind Theo’s back and met every thrust, his weight warm and wonderful on top of her, and when she turned her head Imogen was there, close, and kissed her mouth hungrily. She came with Imogen’s tongue in her mouth and Theo’s name on her lips, and he followed, groaning, his forehead pressed to her neck. Imogen came a moment later, fingers busy, eyes wide and fixed on them both.
Afterwards Theo made coffee in Imogen’s dressing gown, which was far too small for him, and carried it back to bed on a tray.
“For the record,” he said, “I’d have said yes without the dinner.”
“You would not.”
“I’d have said yes to the gin.”
Imogen laughed until she cried.
AD
If you enjoyed this…
Want to bring a little of it to life? Browse couples toys at OhMyGasm. We earn a commission if you buy. 18+ only.
More stories like this